Global Watch | Pakistan’s New Provinces Debate Is About Power, Not Governance
Global Watch | Pakistan’s New Provinces Debate Is About Power, Not Governance
The most troubling aspect of this proposal is the concentration of political power it could facilitate under Asim Munir
Got Question about the News?
A debate has emerged in Pakistan over the creation of new provinces in recent months. It has acquired a significance that goes beyond the arguments of administrative reforms. The proposal is reportedly being pushed by Army Chief Asim Munir and aims to divide the current four provinces of Punjab, Sindh, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan into as many as 15 smaller units. It is being presented as a response to administrative failures and the difficulties of governing a large and diverse population. There is a reasonable case for bringing public institutions closer to citizens. Yet the timing of this debate, the political weight of the existing provinces, and the military establishment’s growing influence over the state raise questions about who stands to gain from redrawing Pakistan’s political map.
A report by The Economist suggests that the proposed restructuring could create 12 to 15 provinces or even a much larger number of administrative territories. The argument of the military-backed current federal government of Shehbaz Sharif rests on the size of the existing units. On one side, Punjab has a population exceeding 127 million (2023 Census), and on the other hand, Balochistan, though with a comparatively smaller population of over 14 million, is the largest province by area. Yet both the provinces face substantial challenges in public administration, with rural communities poorly served and lacking basic infrastructure and access to healthcare, education, and clean drinking water.
Pakistan Army Allegedly Recruiting Ex-Afghan Soldiers, Warlords To Fight Taliban | Exclusive
Shah Rukh Khan Releases New King Poster, Imran Khan’s ‘Leave India’ Deadline Put On Hold Till Nov 2
Honour Commitments First, Talk Nuclear Deal Later: Iran To US As Mecca Pact Allies Seek De-Escalation
Mecca Pact: Pakistan, Saudi, Turkey Leaders Set For Tehran Talks Amid Regional Tensions
The governance issues that Pakistan is confronting today are very real. However, the size of a province alone does not explain why public service delivery across the country remains a failure, as multiple factors contribute. The issues of administrative capacity, resource distribution, fiscal arrangements, political accountability, and the efficacy of local government structures are equally significant in this respect. A smaller province can reproduce the same failures if it inherits an inefficient bureaucracy, inadequate finances and an unaccountable political class. If governance were the principal concern, strengthening elected local governments, improving their service delivery and making provincial departments answerable to citizens would be equally important starting points. As such, the political consequences of the proposal deserve closer scrutiny.
Pakistan’s provinces are more than administrative divisions. Over the years, they have become centres of electoral mobilisation, political patronage, and regional identity in their own right. For instance, Punjab has long been the base of the Sharif family-led Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N), while Sindh remains the bastion of Bhutto-Zardari........
