Blue States Are Putting a Price on Speech |
New York’s attorney general can now go to court to stop a flyer that hasn’t been mailed, provided the state believes it impersonates a union. Gov. Kathy Hochul signed the law on Sept. 9, and its text reaches anyone who “has engaged or is about to engage” in what it defines as false impersonation.
Oregon passed a cousin of that law last year. California followed in August with a privacy law that a conservative journalist is already challenging in federal court. Each one arrives wearing a fraud or safety label. I run a small firm, raised three sons, and I’ve spent years coaching other people’s kids. Two things get my attention fast: a paycheck deduction and a rigged scoreboard. My argument is short. States can punish real deception. They shouldn’t write the rules so loosely that telling workers about their Janus rights becomes a legal gamble. The fix is tighter text, and courts should insist on it.
Start with what the Supreme Court decided. In Janus v. AFSCME, a 5-4 ruling in 2018, the justices held that nonmembers can’t be charged union fees unless they affirmatively consent. Justice Samuel Alito’s majority opinion cited Thomas Jefferson, who called forcing people to fund opinions they disbelieve “sinful and tyrannical.” A right nobody hears about is a nice sentence in a law book. Groups like the Freedom Foundation exist to tell workers it’s there. The group says its mailings have helped more than 35,000 Oregon workers and nearly 7,500 New Yorkers cancel their memberships.
Oregon moved first. House Bill 3789 lets a........