Why the CAPF Bill is a victory for internal security

Opinion National Interest PoV 50-Word Edit

ThePrint On Camera Videos In Pictures

Society & Culture Around Town Book Excerpts Vigyapanti The Dating Story

More Judiciary Education YourTurn Work With Us Campus Voice

Opinion National Interest PoV 50-Word Edit

ThePrint On Camera Videos In Pictures

Society & Culture Around Town Book Excerpts Vigyapanti The Dating Story

More Judiciary Education YourTurn Work With Us Campus Voice

Why the CAPF Bill is a victory for internal security

The ongoing debate around the CAPF General Administration Bill 2026 is not merely about pay scales or promotions.

The Central Armed Police Forces (CAPF) General Administration Bill 2026 represents a pivotal step in fortifying India’s internal security framework while addressing long-standing grievances within the CAPFs. This legislation codifies essential service rules, ensures transparent promotions, fixed tenures, grievance mechanisms, and creates additional senior posts to alleviate career stagnation — all without dismantling the proven coordination mechanisms that have sustained effective operations against Naxalism, insurgency, and terrorism across the country.

Having spent over three decades in the trenches of India’s internal security — leading counter-insurgency operations in Odisha’s Maoist-affected districts, coordinating intelligence grids as IG (Intelligence), ADG, Operations and eventually, steering an entire state police machinery as Director General of Police — I have witnessed first-hand what happens when coordination fails, and the success when it is seamless. The ongoing debate around the CAPF’s new bill is not merely about pay scales or promotions. It is about whether we preserve the institutional steel frame that Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel forged in 1947 or allow career grievances to fracture the very architecture that has kept 1.4 billion citizens safe.

I stand firmly with the new bill. It delivers justice to the brave men and women of the CAPF while safeguarding the federal coordination mechanism that has repeatedly proved its worth in the fight against Naxalism, insurgency, and terrorism. Let me explain why, from the ground level where bullets fly and intelligence must travel faster than rumour.

The coordination imperative: Patel’s vision still holds

When Patel spoke in the Constituent Assembly about the All India Services, he was not being sentimental. He was solving an existential coordination problem. In a country as diverse as India, internal security cannot be a patchwork of insular forces answering only to their own hierarchies. Intelligence Bureau assessments must reach CRPF companies in Chhattisgarh or BSF battalions in Jammu within hours, not days. State police special branches must also share real-time inputs with CISF airport units. District Superintendents of Police (who are IPS) must exercise operational control when CAPFs are deployed to assist them.

My own career is a testament to this. When Naxalism was at its peak in Odisha, we could neutralise entire squads only because IPS officers rotated between state police, IB, CRPF, and intelligence roles. The same officer who once ran a district police station in Malkangiri could later serve in the IB’s Naxal desk and then command a CRPF sector. Those personal relationships — built over joint operations, shared hardships, and trust earned while working in seamless co-ordination — turned raw intelligence into surgical strikes. Remove IPS leadership from senior CAPF command, and you do not just lose one officer; you sever an entire trust network that no new organisational chart can ever hope to rebuild.

Also Read: Govt moves to formalise IPS dominance in top CAPF positions with new bill

Codification of rules: Ending the era of bureaucratic discretion

For decades, CAPF officers have lived with uncertainty. Service conditions, posting tenures, and promotion pathways depended on the whims of the Ministry of Home Affairs file-pushers. (ln CAPF, even after 20 years, one has not become a full-fledged Ccmmandant.) The 2026 bill ends this injustice once and for all. It codifies:

Clear, statutory service rules that every jawan and officer can read and rely upon

Fixed tenure norms for field and staff postings

Transparent medical, family, and hardship allowances

Grievance redressal mechanisms with statutory timelines

This is not cosmetic. When a CRPF company commander in Bastar knows his next promotion is governed by law rather than discretion, his focus shifts to the mission. He is no longer weighed down by his future uncertainty but motivated by its reliability. I have seen officers distracted by endless representations; this bill removes that distraction. Codification is welfare in its purest institutional form — it gives dignity through predictability.

Welfare that actually matters

The real genius of the 2026 bill lies in how it solves the career stagnation of CAPF Group-A officers without touching the federal security architecture. It creates hundreds of new senior posts at DIG, IG, and Additional DG levels. It also faithfully implements the Supreme Court’s Orderly Gradation and Seniority (OGAS) ruling. Furthermore, it removes pay disparities that had rankled for years.

These measures are not “appeasement”; they are justice long overdue for those who have laid down their lives in the same jungles and backwaters where I, too, once operated. Between 1998 and 2020, Odisha alone lost scores of CAPF personnel in joint operations with state police. Their families deserved better career prospects. The new bill delivers exactly that — without the dangerous shortcut demanded by some lobbies: Complete removal of any IPS leadership.

Also Read: ‘We want say in policymaking’: CAPF veterans call IPS deputation bill a ‘consequence of pressure groups’

The Greyhounds–CoBRA lesson: Cross-pollination saves lives

Let me cite living proof. In 1989, IPS officer KS Vyas created the Greyhounds in Andhra Pradesh — an intelligence-driven, jungle-adapted force that became the gold standard of anti-Naxal warfare. The Naxals feared it so much that they assassinated Vyas in 1993. Yet, the doctrine he built lived on. Years later, another IPS officer who had served with the Greyhounds carried the same template into the CRPF and gave brith to the CoBRA (Commando Battalion for Resolute Action). Today, CoBRA is the CRPF’s most effective striking arm.

Crucially and thankfully, the CAPF does not operate in isolation. Under the law, they assist state police under the operational control of the district superintendent of police, who are trained in the IPS. In Odisha, every major Naxal encounter I oversaw succeeded precisely because the CRPF and state police worked under a well coordinated and unified command chain knitted together by IPS officers who had served in both worlds. Insularity would have meant delayed intelligence sharing and fragmented response — the exact failures we cannot afford.

The economic fallacy we must reject

The anti-IPS campaign frames the issue as “dignity versus discrimination.” It is nothing of the sort. It is a classic case of concentrated benefits (faster promotions for a few) versus diffuse but catastrophic costs (weakened national security for 1.4 billion people). Institutional economics teaches us that the most dangerous decisions are those whose costs remain invisible until the next crisis explodes.

The CAPF bill 2026 is a mature, balanced response: it fixes the distributional problem (career stagnation) while preserving the coordination mechanism that Patel had designed. Demolishing 75 years of institutional memory to solve a promotion chart is like burning the bridge because the toll booth needs painting.

Also Read: Cleared UPSC CAPF exam but no force allocation—459 candidates waiting endlessly

A veteran’s final word

I have buried too many young CAPF jawans and IPS colleagues in the red corridor. Their sacrifice demands two things from us — genuine welfare and unshakeable institutional strength. The Bill gives both.

Support the CAPF General Administration Bill 2026.

But above all — preserve the unifying leadership that turns five separate forces into one unbreakable shield for the Republic.

Sardar Patel, the architect of a modern and unified India, envisioned the All India Services — such as the IAS and IPS and later the Indian Forest Services (IFS) — as the indispensable “steel frame” of the nation. In his historic addresses, including to the Constituent Assembly and the first batch of the IAS probationers in 1947, Patel emphasised that these services were crucial for national integration. He argued that without a unified, disciplined, and impartial All India Service, the country would risk fragmentation, as provincial loyalties would undermine central coordination in a federal setup and national cohesion. Patel saw these services as tools to bind the country’s vast diversity under a common administrative and security architecture, ensuring uniform standards, loyalty to the nation, and seamless collaboration across states and central forces. He famously described them as essential to prevent administrative collapse and to foster true national service over parochial interests.

The CAPF General Administration Bill 2026 embodies and advances this very vision of Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel. By preserving IPS leadership in key senior roles within CAPFs — while simultaneously delivering justice through codified rules, expanded promotions via OGAS implementation, and new posts for CAPF cadre officers —the Bill upholds the unifying, coordinating role of the All India Services. It prevents insularity that could fracture intelligence sharing, operational command, and trust networks built across decades of joint operations. In doing so, it safeguards the federal structure Patel designed, where central forces assist states under unified leadership, turning diverse elements into a cohesive shield for the Republic.

This balanced approach, welfare with institutional strength, honours Patel’s foresight that India’s security and unity depend on mechanisms that transcend narrow interests. That is precisely why I strongly support this Bill: it codifies fairness for our brave CAPF personnel while reinforcing the All India Services’ role in national integration, ensuring that the steel frame Patel forged continues to protect 1.4 billion citizens in an era of evolving threats. Sardar Patel, the first Deputy Prime Minister and Home Minister of India, believed in a strong, dedicated civil service, envisioned an AIS — comprising the IAS, IPS and IFS — as the steel frame of the country’s administrative machinery. His vision was to create a merit-based, neutral bureaucracy that would ensure national unity, ensure efficiency in a Federal system where seamless coordination is a must as a stabilising force in a diverse but united India.

Sanjeev Marik is a former Odisha DGP, ex-IG Intelligence, and before that as DIG in three ranges infested with left-wing extremism. He tweets @SanjeevMarik. Views are personal.

(Edited by Insha Jalil Waziri)

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube, Telegram & WhatsApp

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Δdocument.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() );

Graduate and unemployed: India’s middle-class rulebook for career & success no longer works

Infiltration is not a communal issue and ‘love jihad’ is a reality, a crime—RSS’s Sunil Ambekar

‘Robbery victims’ as visa applicants, flights costlier than loot: How FBI cracked staged crime racket

Required fields are marked *

Δdocument.getElementById( "ak_js_2" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() );

ThePrint Hindi ThePrint Tamil ThePrint Marathi ThePrint Store ThePrint Speakers Bureau ThePrint School Of Journalism

© ThePrint

visit website