Why West Bengal Cannot Use the SIR to Block the Right to Food |
Listen to this article:
The architecture of modern constitutional democracies rests upon a simple proposition: different rights serve different purposes and are governed by different legal regimes. The right to vote determines who may participate in democratic governance. The right to food ensures that no person is deprived of the minimum conditions necessary to live with dignity. One of these rights concerns political participation, while the other concerns survival itself.
While both are indispensable rights, the constitution has consciously kept them distinct. A recent executive order issued by the government of West Bengal blurs this distinction. On June 4, 2026, the state government’s Food and Supplies Department issued an order directing authorities to use the outcome of the Election Commission’s Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls as the basis for scrutinising and potentially deleting ration cards of Public Distribution System (PDS) beneficiaries.
Officials were instructed to obtain booth-wise lists of individuals deleted from the electoral roll and to verify and recommend the cancellation of their ration cards, unless they fall within narrowly defined exceptions. The exceptional cases are principally those with pending appeals before the SIR tribunal or applicants under the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2019.
Therefore, the order makes access to food security entitlements contingent upon an electoral verification exercise, effectively linking two statutory regimes that parliament deliberately designed to serve entirely different objectives.
Millions at risk: The human cost of administrative conflation
The Public Distribution System (PDS) is the principal source of food grains for large sections of the working poor, especially informal sector workers, agricultural labourers, senior citizens, widows and marginalised households whose existence remains precarious despite India’s economic growth.
As of April 6, 2026, nearly 91 lakh voters – approximately 11.9% of West Bengal’s electorate – had been removed from voter lists through the SIR exercise. Around 27 lakh appeals against exclusion and another 7 lakh appeals........