We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close
Aa Aa Aa
- A +

New Yorkers fight anti-vaccine Holocaust comparisons via song

4 3 1
29.08.2021

JTA — It was a quiet Shabbat afternoon when the frustration that had been building up inside Michal Schick spilled out in a song.

For months, Schick had been keeping a tally in her head — and sometimes on Twitter, where the New York City screenwriter is active — of pandemic-related Holocaust comparisons that, to her and many others, made no sense at all.

There were the people who said staying home made them feel like Anne Frank. The politicians comparing mask requirements to the Nazis’ race laws. And, increasingly, the yellow stars worn by anti-vaccination activists.

Around the world, these images and ideas have alarmed Jews and others who don’t understand how measures aimed at preserving health can be likened in any way to the Nazis’ murder of 6 million Jews in the Holocaust. Antisemitism watchdogs including the Anti-Defamation League have called repeatedly for the analogies to stop, saying that they trivialize a tragedy of incomparable proportions.

Schick took a different approach. She scribbled down some lyrics and reached out to her friend Avishai Weinberger to ask if he knew anyone who played the ukulele.

“It’s a more fun way to process it than just to be screaming in your head all the time,” she said.

The result of their collaboration is “The Anti-Vaxxer’s Lament,” a two-minute song that pillories Holocaust comparisons in the COVID-19 era. In a video posted this week, Weinberger’s mother, a children’s musician named Naomi Weinberger, strums an upbeat tune as he sings Schick’s words, written from the perspective of someone who rejects vaccines.

“My life is like the Holocaust. I say this with great pride,” one verse goes. “’Cause public health and........

© The Times of Israel


Get it on Google Play