Hanukkah commonly evokes light, family gatherings, and childhood memory. But these associations sit atop a much deeper and more challenging history.

Hanukkah marks the only successful Jewish revolt in recorded antiquity against cultural erasure.

Not against slavery. Not against imperial taxation. Not against foreign rule as such.

Against forced assimilation.

The Seleucid decrees were not primarily economic or political. They were civilizational. They targeted the infrastructure of Jewish continuity itself: Torah law and study, Hebrew language, Shabbat, circumcision, and the Jewish calendar. Torah scrolls were destroyed, and those who taught or possessed them were executed. In effect, the decrees aimed to dismantle Jewish memory.

Most ancient peoples who faced comparable pressures disappeared. Their names survive, if at all, as archaeological layers or linguistic footnotes. Jews did not. Hanukkah is the reason why. It is, in this sense, a historical anomaly.

An Intra-Jewish War Before It Was a Foreign One

The popular narrative frames Hanukkah as Jews versus Greeks. This is not completely inaccurate.

A significant portion of the conflict was intra-Jewish. The earliest battles of the Maccabean revolt were fought not against Seleucid forces, but against Jews who had embraced Hellenization and sought to redefine Judaism as a civic, aesthetic, or philosophical identity compatible with imperial norms.

This was not a dispute about........

© The Times of Israel (Blogs)