To my surprise, and perhaps yours, the last time Pinchas appears in Tanach, he is not holding a spear.

During the civil war against the tribe of Binyamin, Sefer Shoftim (the Book of Judges) tells us:

“Pinchas son of Elazar son of Aharon stood before it in those days” (Shoftim 20:28).

The Radak (a 13th-century biblical commentator) explains that Pinchas was serving as Kohen Gadol, standing before the Aron with the Urim and Tumim. The same Pinchas who once took a spear in his hand now stands before Hashem seeking guidance before action is taken.

This is not the Pinchas we remember.

In our parasha, he is often portrayed as a young zealot, acting decisively in a moment of national crisis. In Shoftim, we meet an elderly spiritual leader asking: “Shall I continue to wage war against the children of Binyamin my brother, or shall I desist?”

The man who once acted now consults. The man who once intervened now deliberates.

It is tempting to see these as two version of Pinchas, and to assume that the older one corrected the younger. I disagree.

The Torah praises the young Pinchas, and Tanach honours the older Pinchas. Both are held up for us to remember. Perhaps the lesson is not that one was right and the other wrong, but that there is a time for each.

There are moments when a nation needs the Kohen Gadol standing before the Aron, seeking guidance. There are also moments when evil is so brazen, danger so immediate, and hesitation so costly that action cannot wait.

Understanding how the same person embodied both roles may be the key to understanding not only Pinchas himself, but why the Torah ultimately praises him. The young Pinchas is not the norm, but he is the role model for those rare moments when action cannot wait.

Let us recall what he did.

Zimri and Cozbi engaged in a brazen act of public immorality and idolatry, seemingly designed to challenge Moshe’s authority and push the nation into further spiritual collapse.

“Pinchas son of Elazar son of Aharon the........

© The Times of Israel (Blogs)