The phrase was Lloyd George’s; the faith was Patel’s. When the Sardar rose in the Constituent Assembly in October 1949 to defend the services he had insisted on retaining, he converted an imperial instrument into a constitutional one, and the steel frame became the republic’s load-bearing wall. One of us (Ranjan) joined that frame more than two decades ago, and as the district magistrate at Hazaribag, he once made a private calculation: a district magistrate signs his name well over a hundred times a day. Some signatures needed his mind.

Many, he admits, needed only his wrist. We have thought of that arithmetic constantly this past year, because a technology has arrived that writes, argues and drafts, and the question before the Indian state is the oldest one in administration wearing new clothes: what may be delegated, and what may never be. Let it be recorded first that the government has not been caught sleeping. Under Mission Karmayogi, the iGOT platform now carries over 1.7 crore registered officials and more than 5,600 courses in 23 languages; its 218 courses on artificial intelligence and emerging technologies have logged over seven crore enrolments; and from this year, prescribed courses are mandatory for central employees and All India Services officers, linked to their annual appraisals.

The steel is already in the furnace. What remains to be settled is the temper, and that is the subject of this essay, in three arguments. The first argument begins with a homage. The humble note-sheet, mocked in a thousand cartoons, is in truth India’s original reasoning engine. Precedent is retrieved, alternatives are weighed, objections are recorded, and a named officer takes responsibility in ink; the file is accountability made visible. Now observe what a large language model is: a note-writer of superhuman speed and no conscience.

It can draft in seconds........

© The Statesman