Kulgam and Kishtwar: Collective Punishment Is Not Security

Kulgam and Kishtwar: Collective Punishment Is Not Security

Rights advocates allege collective punishment, mass detentions, custodial torture and a disputed killing in Kulgam, and unanswered questions over the deaths of two Special Police Officers in Kishtwar.

The reports coming out of Kulgam and Kishtwar in November 2026 call for more than another official statement about “security.” They call for an independent investigation, public accountability and immediate steps to protect civilians.

Local accounts cited by rights advocates allege that whole communities were punished after individual security incidents, that detainees were tortured, and that a man was killed after being taken into custody. These are serious claims. They should not be brushed aside because they implicate state forces—but they should not be treated as proven without credible evidence, either. The way to resolve them is to allow scrutiny, not shut it down.

In Kulgam, the reported trigger was an attack on a CRPF vehicle on 11 November. According to local accounts, what followed was an eight-day operation involving the Army, CRPF and Special Operations Group. Cordon-and-search operations allegedly restricted entire neighbourhoods, making it difficult for residents to obtain food, water, medicine and emergency care. Residents also described women, children and older people being made to stand outside in freezing weather during house searches.

This  would mean people were made to suffer for acts they had not individually committed. Collective punishment is prohibited under international humanitarian law. Security concerns cannot be used as a blanket excuse to deprive civilians of necessities or subject them to fear and hardship.

The allegations of mass detention are just as troubling. The accounts cited in the original draft say nearly 700 people, mostly young men, were........

© The Destination