Why Challenges to a Fair Count in Mississippi and Alaska Will Fall Flat |
This is Executive Dysfunction, a newsletter that highlights one under-the-radar story about how Trump is changing the law—and how the law is pushing back—and keeps you posted on the latest from Slate’s Jurisprudence team. Click here to receive it in your inbox each week.
Tensions were high going into Election Day, not only because control of Congress was up for grabs but also because President Donald Trump and his administration had spent months attempting to interfere with states’ electoral processes. Lawsuits were filed, letters were sent, and threats were made, yet in the end Democratic candidates across the country notched definitive wins with margins that, in the words of Trump, were simply “too big to rig.” Even Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton—and Trump himself—was forced to concede defeat. The judiciary played a major role in tamping down frivolous legal challenges before the vote, and now Democrats, with their handsome majorities in both the House and Senate, have a mandate to fulfill.
Consequentially, the two biggest legal challenges that consumed the days leading up to the midterms have effectively been shut down. The Department of Justice’s lawsuit against California election officials, which argued that they must set aside some 20,000 mail ballots the federal government suspected of being cast by noncitizens, was shut down by the U.S. Supreme Court on Monday. And the day before, a federal judge dismissed the DOJ’s lawsuit in Alaska, which sought to separate and preserve certain ballots cast in the state’s Senate election in the event that Republican Dan S. Sullivan lost his race. Across the country, in almost every instance of the DOJ suing states for access to their voter rolls, the federal government lost its case.
With all of that said, it’s worth looking at what the state of play is for any ongoing election challenges with a pair of major Senate races and a number of House seats yet to be called. The AFL-CIO, one of the largest national labor unions, sued the DOJ to stop it from demanding that state and local election officials separate disputed ballots and threatening prosecution if those ballots were counted. The case has been ping-ponging between judges at the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, and on Election Day, the AFL-CIO asked the full court to weigh in—all 29 federal judges—and it remains to be seen where that may take this case. Over in Alaska, there was also new DOJ activity; this time, the agency sent 20 Democrats letters informing them that they may be targets of a federal investigation over........