This Is What It Takes to Win a Can’t-Win Race |
Sign up for the Slatest to get the most insightful analysis, criticism, and advice out there, delivered to your inbox daily.
Coming out of Democrats’ wild success in the midterms, there were the winners who had fought heated battles in the glare of the national spotlight. And then there were those who had just barely registered on the national radar. When Slate wrote of Texas’ 23rd district, for example, we wrote of the boorishness of the Republican nominee and barely mentioned the Democrat, Katy Padilla Stout, given that the district had voted for President Donald Trump by a 15-point margin in 2024. Padilla Stout won by 8 points.
Many of these long-shot candidates weren’t blessed by the resources of the national party until late in the game, if at all. They were left to launch quixotic bids in districts thought to be immovable, and in districts that in some cases had been redrawn to give Republicans easy victories. And against all odds, some of these candidates succeeded.
In the days since the election, the rest of the country has scrambled to learn who these newcomers are and how they managed to flip their seats. Others chuckled at the thought that some everyday people in red states launching symbolic challenges with no actual expectation of winning would suddenly find themselves part of Congress. But if you talk to the candidates, you’ll find something striking: confidence, and a decent amount of disdain for the doubters.
Paul Barringer, formerly a healthcare lawyer in D.C. who unseated a Trump-backed incumbent in North Carolina’s gerrymandered 13th District, ran after moving back to rural North Carolina to care for his ailing mother. He had been a Republican, but he was galled by what he saw as the corruption and chaos and excesses of the Trump administration. We reached him Friday, as he was still trying to catch up on all his messages from election night. (“You ever had 600 text messages come into your phone?” he said. “How ’bout that boss that was really terrible to you, and told you you’d never amount to anything because you were too nice, reaching out to you?”) He knew he could win, he said. When pressed, he doubled down, insistent that he had always been confident.
“Yeah, I mean, I felt that,” he said. “Maybe I was deluded.”
Most people........