The “Replace Schumer” Movement Is Growing. We Know Where This Ends. |
This story is adapted from the Slatest newsletter. You can sign up here to get it in your inbox every day.
Well, that was fast. Despite the Democrats’ historic midterm win, party unity is already fraying over the most basic of questions: Who should lead their party in the House and Senate? A band of mostly progressive lawmakers and activists is trying to derail Sen. Chuck Schumer’s bid to reclaim his position as Senate majority leader. In Congress’ lower chamber, a parallel effort is underway to thwart Rep. Hakeem Jeffries’ attempt to become the first Black speaker of the House. Neither rebellion seems particularly likely to succeed, but even their failure may tell us a lot about the Democrats’ future.
What are progressives doing to resist Schumer and Jeffries?
Some, like Sen. Bernie Sanders, have made it clear that they won’t support Schumer. Others are coalescing around an alternative: Sen. Chris Van Hollen, a Maryland Democrat who has made inroads with progressives by backing “Medicare for All” and voting to cut off U.S. arms sales to Israel. Van Hollen hasn’t yet declared a challenge to Schumer ahead of next month’s vote but says he’s “actively listening” to colleagues who have encouraged him to.
Meanwhile, progressive activist groups are urging voters to contact their representatives and pressure them not to support Jeffries. Hundreds of anti-Jeffries calls and emails have reportedly flooded congressional offices since the midterms. And although no challenger has yet emerged, there’s still time; the vote to elect a new House speaker will take place in January, after newly elected lawmakers take their seats.
So are Schumer and Jeffries in real trouble?
No, and they won’t be unless things change dramatically. Schumer needs to win only a majority of the Senate Democratic caucus to become leader, and he appears on track to do that. Had Democrats won fewer Senate seats last week, the effort to block him might have more juice. As it is, it’s hard to argue that your party is in desperate need of new leaders when its old leaders just helped deliver........