Democrats Just Won an Impressive Senate Majority. But It Could’ve Been Even Bigger. |
This story is adapted from the Slatest newsletter. You can sign up here to get it in your inbox every day.
For Democrats, the past two weeks have been one long celebration. The party officially clinched its 55th Senate seat on Wednesday night and remains on track to win a 56th as election officials continue to count ballots in Alaska. Senators and strategists are already salivating over the prospect of winning 60 seats or more come 2028, a majority that would be big enough to override Republican filibusters.
But could they actually have gotten one sooner? But for a little more party coordination, slightly better candidates, and a smidge more money, there’s a strong case that Democrats could be basking in a 60-seat majority right now. Let’s take a look at four Senate races where the party came tantalizingly close last week—and at how things could have turned out differently.
A Failure to Coordinate in Montana
At first glance, Big Sky Country doesn’t look like much of a missed opportunity for Democrats. After all, Republican Kurt Alme ran more than 10 points ahead of Seth Bodnar, his closest challenger. But Bodnar was running as an independent, and the Democrat who won the primary, Alani Bankhead, rebuffed repeated calls to drop out to avoid splitting the vote. Alme ended up winning with just 48 percent of ballots cast, so it’s quite possible that Bodnar would have beaten him had Bankhead shelved her ego.
She isn’t the only person at fault, though. Bodnar, a former Democrat, could have chosen to run under the party standard. If he had instead beaten Bankhead in the Democratic primary, it’s possible he’d have gone on to defeat Alme with a D next to his name. There are no sure things with any of these races, but the divided vote certainly didn’t help.
A Recruiting Flop in Louisiana
Democrats put up an impressive showing across the South, padding their majority by winning........