[Whispers] The Democratic Party Is Good at Politics |
Sign up for the Slatest to get the most insightful analysis, criticism, and advice out there, delivered to your inbox daily.
Making fun of the Democratic Party has long been a bipartisan pastime. “I don’t belong to any organized political faith. I am a Democrat,” the actor Will Rogers said in 1933. Nearly a century later, Donald Trump mocks the party as “Dumbocrats.” Democrats in disarray has become a cliché among beltway journalists. A screenshot from a 1994 episode of The Simpsons, which depicts a Democratic convention unfolding beneath slogans like “We cant govern!” and “We hate life and ourselves,” circulates on social media with dismal frequency. In an AP/NORC poll last year, voters described the party as “weak,” “ineffective,” and “generally bad.” And those voters were Democrats.
A similar undercurrent of belittlement is already detectable after Tuesday’s midterms, which resoundingly swept Democrats back into power in Congress, governors’ mansions, and hundreds of other seats across the country. “Will Democrats Misread Their Victory?” the Wall Street Journal wonders. “Democrats, Don’t Mess This Up,” admonishes the Intercept. The skepticism is coming from inside the (literal) House, too. “I’m really worried that we’re going to misread victory as an endorsement of us or America falling in love with Democrats,” Rep. Jim Himes of Connecticut told Time magazine. “We need to remember that we have been asked to audition for a role in which the party has failed.” It’s as if the whole country can’t help but picture Democrats stepping on a rake at the earliest possible opportunity.
Governing is harder than campaigning, so those concerns aren’t totally unjustified. Yet the midterm results highlight an important truth that has long gone underappreciated: Democrats really aren’t so bad at this whole politics thing. Derided on the left and right as unpopular, out-of-touch quislings, Democrats proved last night that they remain plenty adaptable, resilient, and effective at winning power. Unlike the GOP, which has been in thrall to Trumpism for a decade, and despite Americans’ growing disenchantment with political parties in general, Democrats still behave the way an effective political party should: recalibrating after defeats, adjusting messages as the political environment shifts, backing quality candidates, and tolerating a broad spectrum of ideologies and voices under one umbrella. Parties exist to win elections, and on that score this donkey remains alive and kicking.
I can hear the objections already: Didn’t Democrats fumble two presidential races against Trump? And isn’t the chief architect of the party’s midterm victories actually the president himself, who spiked prices with tariffs and a war? Yes and yes. No point in sugarcoating it: Losing to Trump not once but twice has been hugely costly, not least for the Democrats’ brand. And both times, the party made major missteps. In 2016, Democrats ignored warning signs while clearing the field for Hillary Clinton, a candidate who was a poor match for the moment. In 2024, the party did the right thing by pushing Joe Biden out of the race over widespread concerns about his age, but they did so too late—and paid for it........