Island's voters actually got to pick judges |
I voted for judges this year. I blame Jon Estreich.
As the Democratic Party candidate for Suffolk County comptroller, Estreich upended party bosses' plans by taking a principled stand that led to — gasp! — a competitive election for state Supreme Court justices on Long Island.
For over a decade those elections were shells of democracy — an equal number of open seats as cross-endorsed candidates meant the races were uncontested. Eight seats, eight candidates. Party leaders picked who wears the robes, not voters.
Even worse, voters were duped into thinking they were participating in democracy by voting when the winners were known the moment they were chosen at judicial conventions every August. Political insiders knew earlier.
It's like a football game with one team on the field.
A roundup of highlights from Newsday's Opinion Department.
By clicking Sign up, you agree to our privacy policy.
But this year, the Island's........