The most corrosive feature of contemporary political discourse in Jammu and Kashmir is not disagreement but the systematic manufacture of fear. When public representatives begin to describe routine fiscal instruments as existential threats, governance is replaced by theatre and policy by panic. The claim advanced by PDP legislator Waheed Para that the Special Assistance to States for Capital Investment (SASCI) is a “debt trap" through which Jammu and Kashmir is being sold — its land, water bodies, institutions, villages and mountains allegedly handed over — belongs squarely to this genre of politics. It is a claim that collapses the moment it is subjected to legal, financial or even basic logical scrutiny.

To speak of “selling" a place is to invoke a very precise idea. Sale requires a seller, a buyer, a transferable asset and a legally enforceable transaction. None of these elements exist in the SASCI framework. What is being presented as dispossession is, in fact, a 50-year, interest-free capital investment loan provided by the Union government to states and Union Territories for the creation of public infrastructure. No land is mortgaged. No asset is pledged. No institution is transferred. There is no clause, hidden or explicit, that allows the Centre to appropriate territory or resources in exchange for finance. To describe such an arrangement as a sale is not a difference of interpretation; it is a distortion of meaning.

The rhetoric becomes even........

© News18