Angry NJ drivers aim to slay NY’s hated congestion toll — here’s how |
US News Metro Long Island Politics
Sports NFL MLB Olympics NBA NHL College Football College Basketball WNBA
Business Personal Finance
Entertainment TV Movies Music Celebrities Awards Theater
Lifestyle Weird But True Sex & Relationships Viral Trends Human Interest Parenting Fashion & Beauty Food & Drink Travel
Health Wellness Fitness Health Care Medicine Men’s Health Women’s Health Mental Health Nutrition
Science Space Environment Wildlife Archaeology
Today’s Paper Covers Columnists Horoscopes Crosswords & Games Sports Odds Podcasts Careers
Email Newsletters Official Store Home Delivery Tips
Switch between CA and NY editions here.
Angry NJ drivers aim to slay NY’s hated congestion toll — here’s how
When a federal district judge this month blocked President Donald Trump’s attempt to terminate congestion pricing, MTA CEO Janno Lieber cheered: “The Manhattan tolls are here to stay,” he declared.
Judge Lewis Liman’s ruling concerned a single question: Did the federal Department of Transportation have the authority to yank its prior agreement to the toll program?
The judge answered that it did not.
But his ruling didn’t resolve the bigger issue: whether the MTA ever had the legal authority to start charging tolls on Manhattan’s streets in the first place.
Mamdani’s 15 mph speed limit plan threatens to turn NYC into city that never moves — just like London
NYC subway ridership still trail pre-COVID numbers — but MTA claims congestion pricing is helping
A Luigi Mangione musical and more: Letters to the Editor — March 8, 2026
That very different question is now squarely before a federal court in New Jersey.
And the answer, I believe, is no.
Here’s what the MTA doesn’t want drivers to understand: Federal law generally prohibits tolling on federally funded roads.
The MTA claims it’s entitled to a special dispensation through a federal program called the Value Pricing Pilot Program, a statutory exception that has permitted certain tolling experiments on qualifying roads.
There are two fatal defects with that contention.
For one thing, the VPPP is defunct.
The program expressly requires federal funding of any project operating under its authority — and Congress hasn’t appropriated a single dollar for the VPPP since 2012.
A program that requires federal money to operate cannot legally do so when the federal money dried up over a decade ago.
There’s also a second, independent problem: Even if the VPPP was still up and running, it still wouldn’t apply to the roads MTA is tolling.
The VPPP applied only to roads on the federal interstate system.
And the streets in downtown Manhattan where the MTA is collecting its $9 toll — streets like 57th Street, Lexington Avenue and 3rd Avenue below 60th — are not part of that system: They are federally funded arterial roads.
The statutory exception the MTA invoked simply doesn’t apply to the roads it’s actually charging drivers to use.
Put these two defects together and the conclusion is unavoidable: The MTA has been scooping up tolls it had no legal right to collect, starting from the very first day the congestion-pricing program launched in January 2025.
By our estimate, drivers have been illegally soaked for approximately $600 million.
Under the law, that money must be returned.
A class-action lawsuit asserting these claims on behalf of drivers is pending before Judge Leo M. Gordon in the US District Court for the District of New Jersey.
The case, Dunne v. Metropolitan Transportation Authority, has the backing of the New Jersey Conference of Mayors, the New Jersey General Assembly Republican membership and the Board of Commissioners of Warren County.
I am a supporter because my constituents are being robbed by these illegal tolls.
To date, the MTA has offered no answer as to how its program can survive either one of its two independently fatal defects — let alone both of them.
Congestion pricing’s impact on New Jersey is substantial.
The congestion-pricing zone runs directly along the New Jersey–New York border.
And according to the MTA’s own projected tolling scenarios, New Jersey drivers bear a greater share of the toll burden than Manhattan residents do.
This program was designed to extract more money from the people of New Jersey than from the people of the borough it supposedly serves.
Congestion pricing launched in the final days of Joe Biden’s presidency, under the auspices of a Biden-era federal agreement.
Six weeks later Trump’s new transportation secretary, Sean Duffy, moved to rescind that agreement.
The MTA sued, and Judge Liman’s ruling that Duffy lacked the authority to make his unilateral call was the result.
But that’s it. That’s all the judge decided.
The lawsuit before Judge Gordon is about a different fight, a more fundamental one: whether this program was ever lawful to begin with.
The New Jersey class action is fighting to get drivers their money back, every last dollar.
This is a lawsuit filed by ordinary people who were wrongfully charged tolls that were never legally authorized, banding together to recover what was taken from them.
When a government agency takes money it had no authority to collect, the law requires it to be returned.
This month’s ruling does nothing to extinguish that $600 million (and growing) liability. It doesn’t even address it.
Declare a hollow victory if you’d like, Mr. Lieber.
Just don’t spend it yet — this train hasn’t reached its destination.
Paul Kanitra represents Ocean County in New Jersey’s general assembly.
department of transportation
manhattan federal court
Kirsten Fleming Jerry O'Connell sums up the Dem dilemma perfectly — even if he did have to get beaten up for it
Jerry O'Connell sums up the Dem dilemma perfectly — even if he did have to get beaten up for it
Rich Lowry Trump is owned by no one — driving some former allies nuts
Trump is owned by no one — driving some former allies nuts
Miranda Devine The FBI's repeated non-answers on US terrorism attacks raise alarming red flags
The FBI's repeated non-answers on US terrorism attacks raise alarming red flags
Front Cover Back Cover
Trending Now on NYPost.com
This story has been shared 98,963 times. 98,963 Missing Alabama student's body recovered in Barcelona
Missing Alabama student's body recovered in Barcelona
This story has been shared 91,008 times. 91,008 Iran executes 19-year-old champion wrestler, two others in horrific public hangings
Iran executes 19-year-old champion wrestler, two others in horrific public hangings
This story has been shared 28,406 times. 28,406 Major cruise line cancels planned sailings, upending vacations: 'Definitely a disappointment'
Major cruise line cancels planned sailings, upending vacations: 'Definitely a disappointment'
ABC cancels Taylor Frankie Paul's season of 'The Bachelorette'
Stream It Or Skip It: 'Imperfect Women' On Apple TV, Where A Murder Unearths Secrets Among A Group Of Longtime Friends
Iran executes 19-year-old champion wrestler, two others in horrific public hangings
Sections & Features US News Metro World News Sports Sports Betting Business Opinion Entertainment Fashion & Beauty Shopping Lifestyle Real Estate Media Tech Science Health Travel Astrology Video Photos Alexa Covers Horoscopes Sports Odds Podcasts Crosswords & Games Columnists Classifieds
Post Sports+ Subscribe Articles Manage
Newsletters & Feeds Email Newsletters RSS Feeds NY Post Official Store Home Delivery Subscribe Manage Subscription Delivery Help
NY Post Official Store
Home Delivery Subscribe Manage Subscription
Help/Support About New York Post Editorial Standards New York Post Awards & Recognition Customer Service Apps Help Community Guidelines Contact Us Tips Newsroom Letters to the Editor Licensing & Reprints Careers Vulnerability Disclosure Program
New York Post Awards & Recognition
Contact Us Tips Newsroom Letters to the Editor Licensing & Reprints Careers Vulnerability Disclosure Program
Letters to the Editor
Vulnerability Disclosure Program
Apps iPhone App iPad App Android Phone Android Tablet
Advertise Media Kit Contact