The Guardian Myth: Why America’s Hormuz Toll Plan Is Already Sinking

Washington has crowned itself toll-collector of the world’s most important—and dangerous—waterway, yet it cannot guarantee a single tanker will cross that waterway alive.

A Toll with No Legal Foundation

The plan also collapses on its own arithmetic. No one, including apparently the White House, has explained how the 20 percent figure would be calculated. For instance, shippers cannot even evaluate whether the service is worth buying until someone specifies the base: is it 20 percent of the Navy’s blockade costs, divided across vessels, or a straight levy on cargo value? A toll regime that cannot define its own base is not policy; it is a Truth Social post dressed up as one.

And even a fully specified fee would not settle the matter, because the ultimate gatekeepers of Hormuz traffic are not naval commanders but insurance underwriters. Maritime law specialists note that insurers can simply refuse to cover vessels transiting the strait if they judge the risk too high, regardless of whether an owner is willing to pay Washington for protection. Lloyd’s of London, not CENTCOM, may end up deciding whether the “Guardian” title means anything at........

© New Eastern Outlook