menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Tusk’s Constitutional Power Grab: Is Poland’s Court Crisis Clearing the Way for a Federal Europe?

113 0
04.11.2026

Tusk’s Constitutional Power Grab: Is Poland’s Court Crisis Clearing the Way for a Federal Europe?

Donald Tusk returned to office promising to restore the rule of law. On October 30, that promise produced a confrontation at Poland’s Constitutional Tribunal, the court charged with reviewing legislation and international agreements against the constitution.

The next day, Nawrocki called the events a forcible takeover of a constitutional institution. Tusk responded in a televised address by comparing the dispute to recovering a stolen handbag. The supposed thief, in his analogy, complains of violence when the rightful owner tries to recover her property. “In certain matters there can be no compromise,” the prime minister insisted.

It was a revealing argument from a government invoking legality to defend measures whose legal foundation was being challenged even by prominent opponents of Poland’s previous conservative administration. The stakes reach beyond a Warsaw courthouse. The institution at the centre of the dispute has already challenged Brussels over the limits of EU authority, while a separate confrontation over the independence of Poland’s central bank is approaching.

The Court That Challenged Brussels

The latest escalation began when a judge elected under Tusk’s parliamentary majority ordered a month-long interruption of the official duties of the Tribunal’s president and deputy. They rejected her authority. Further orders restricted access to the premises and altered working arrangements for staff. Poland’s justice minister, who also serves as prosecutor general, submitted five applications seeking to lift the judicial immunity of the two leaders.

Police maintained that officers were protecting the building rather than occupying it. But the question of legality cannot be settled by the government’s account of its intentions. A constitutional scholar known for his criticism of the previous conservative government’s judicial reforms declared that there was no legal basis for suspending the Tribunal president. He considered that official wholly unsuitable for the post, yet rejected the procedure used against him.

That objection exposes the weakness of Tusk’s claim to be simply repairing the rule of law. A government cannot make an act constitutional by describing its opponents as thieves.

The court’s importance to Brussels is established by experience. In 2021, it rejected certain interpretations of EU treaties as incompatible with Poland’s constitutional order. The clash raised a fundamental........

© New Eastern Outlook