Opinion | Beyond Anger: Understanding Sikh Concerns And Trust Deficit

Updated: Jun 01, 2026 18:55 pm IST Published On Jun 01, 2026 18:54 pm IST Last Updated On Jun 01, 2026 18:55 pm IST

Published On Jun 01, 2026 18:54 pm IST

Last Updated On Jun 01, 2026 18:55 pm IST

Sikh sentiment towards India, especially in parts of the diaspora, is often seen through emotion and slogans. But the reality is far more layered and complex.

The issue needs to be examined through the lens of historical trauma, political mistrust, identity concerns, security debates, economic anxieties and evolving efforts at reconciliation.

At the heart of this debate lies one crucial word: trust.

Historical Trauma and Collective Memory

For many Sikhs, especially those who either witnessed or inherited memories of the 1980s and early 1990s during the Congress-led government, the emotional scars of Operation Blue Star and the 1984 anti-Sikh violence, described by many Sikh groups and survivors as genocide, remain deeply significant.

At the same time, Punjab also suffered a violent insurgency, affecting civilians, police personnel, and political leaders. This duality, between state security concerns and community trauma, continues to define much of the Sikh-state debate even decades later.

Punjab has an estimated population of over 3.2 crore. As per the 2011 Census, Sikhs form 57.7% of Punjab's population and around 1.7% of India's population.

These figures are important because they show that Sikh concerns cannot be understood merely as a minority issue. They are deeply connected with Punjab's history, India's federal structure, national security, diaspora politics and the emotional memory of a community that has contributed immensely to India.

The Diaspora and Trust Deficit

The Punjabi and Sikh diaspora today is among the most influential Indian-origin communities globally. Over the years, successive governments in India have attempted certain confidence-building measures toward Sikhs, especially the diaspora community. One such step was the removal of names of several overseas Sikhs from the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)-led government "blacklists". For decades, many expatriate Sikhs, particularly from Canada, the United Kingdom and the United States, alleged that they faced difficulties visiting India due to suspicions linked to the militancy period.

The removal of these names from the blacklist was projected as a gesture of outreach and reconciliation. Yet an uncomfortable and largely unanswered question remains: how many of those individuals actually returned to India after their names were removed from the blacklist?

That question reflects the depth of the trust deficit.

Many among the diaspora continue to fear that even if formal restrictions are lifted by the Union government, old police records, dormant cases, or........

© NDTV