California’s Budget Has Ballooned—Taxes Should Not

California’s state budget increased by about 75 percent in the past eight years, despite no population growth, rising from around $201 billion in fiscal year 2018–19 to more than $350 billion in fiscal year 2026–27. This represents around $25,500 of state spending per household.  With such a large rise in spending, the last thing politicians should be asking for is higher taxes.

Yet the state’s Democratic Party has endorsed both Proposition 3, which would make the top personal income tax rate of 13.3 percent permanent, and Proposition 40, which would retroactively take 5 percent of wealth from Californians with a net worth of over $1 billion.   

California’s 13.3 percent top personal income tax is the highest in the country. Its genesis was a ballot proposition known as “Temporary Taxes to Fund Education,” which was passed by voters in 2012 after a plea by Governor Jerry Brown. He marketed the 3 percentage point increase on top earners (over $1 million for joint filers) as a temporary sacrifice that would avoid deep cuts to schools and public safety during California’s 2012 fiscal crisis. It also increased tax rates on other high earners and raised sales taxes by 0.25 percentage points, though for four years rather than seven years.

In his 2013 “State of the State” speech, Brown referenced the Bible when stating, “The people have given us seven years of extra taxes. Let us follow the wisdom of Joseph, pay down our debts, and store up reserves against the leaner times that will surely come.”

But those seven years of revenue abundance became fourteen years and counting: In 2016, voters extended those higher tax rates until 2031.

Fast forward from 2016 to 2026, and the state’s Democratic leadership and school unions are asking voters to pass Proposition 3 and make sure those higher taxes never go away.

The “temporary” fix that never ends

The advertisements for Proposition 3, largely funded by $33 million from the California Teachers Association, emphasize saving school funding, but California can always repurpose some of its budget increase to schools. Moreover, schools are already well-funded; the 2026–27 California school budget is $151 billion, which is an estimated $26,800 per child. Assuming an average classroom size of twenty-three students within California schools, the budget works out to about $600,000 per classroom.

There is no doubt........

© Hoover Institution