The U.S. and Israel Aren’t Fighting the Same War

Get audio access with any FP subscription. Subscribe Now ALREADY AN FP SUBSCRIBER? LOGIN

Get audio access with any FP subscription.

ALREADY AN FP SUBSCRIBER? LOGIN

Last week, U.S. President Donald Trump said that there is “practically nothing left to target” in Iran and that the U.S.-Israeli war there will end “soon.” Hours later, Israeli Defense Minister Israel Katz said that the war will continue “without any time limit, for as long as necessary, until we achieve all the objectives and decisively win the campaign.”

The gap between these two statements is not a messaging problem. It is the problem. The United States and Israel are not fighting the same war.

Last week, U.S. President Donald Trump said that there is “practically nothing left to target” in Iran and that the U.S.-Israeli war there will end “soon.” Hours later, Israeli Defense Minister Israel Katz said that the war will continue “without any time limit, for as long as necessary, until we achieve all the objectives and decisively win the campaign.”

The gap between these two statements is not a messaging problem. It is the problem. The United States and Israel are not fighting the same war.

There is an exit strategy that would allow the United States to end the war on its terms without surrendering to Israel’s agenda. Last year, when the costs of fighting the Houthis began to outweigh the benefits, Trump negotiated with the militant group to reach a bilateral cease-fire that did not include Israel or other regional actors. The United States stopped fighting; Israel and others, including Saudi Arabia and Yemen, kept going. Trump called it a win.

He should do it again.

Trump wanted a Venezuela moment in Iran, according to New York Times reporting: strike fast, decapitate the leadership, install someone friendlier, declare victory, and go home with minimal cost to the United States. He said so himself. “What we did in Venezuela, I think, is the perfect, the perfect scenario,” Trump told the Times on March 1, in a phone interview focused on........

© Foreign Policy