No One Has a Plan for American Decline

Get audio access with any FP subscription. Subscribe Now ALREADY AN FP SUBSCRIBER? LOGIN

Get audio access with any FP subscription.

ALREADY AN FP SUBSCRIBER? LOGIN

America’s geopolitical power is crumbling, and that shouldn’t be too much of a surprise. Hegemons, after all, rise and fall. Yet nobody in U.S. politics or punditry seems to actually want to talk about the consequences, especially for the American people. When it comes to decline, they either believe it won’t happen or won’t matter—in other words, that America can’t decline or that Americans will be just fine if it does.

Many in the neoconservative and traditionally conservative wings of the Republican Party believe that with the renewed application of its still considerable military and political power, America can remain the world’s dominant power for the foreseeable future. Republican restrainers, in turn, believe that if America forsakes dominance and conserves its power, global disorder can be kept at bay and the American people will be better for it. And while key figures in President Donald Trump’s orbit are all too worried about decline in racial or civilizational terms, they have their own dangerous and counterproductive ideas for how to reverse it.

America’s geopolitical power is crumbling, and that shouldn’t be too much of a surprise. Hegemons, after all, rise and fall. Yet nobody in U.S. politics or punditry seems to actually want to talk about the consequences, especially for the American people. When it comes to decline, they either believe it won’t happen or won’t matter—in other words, that America can’t decline or that Americans will be just fine if it does.

Many in the neoconservative and traditionally conservative wings of the Republican Party believe that with the renewed application of its still considerable military and political power, America can remain the world’s dominant power for the foreseeable future. Republican restrainers, in turn, believe that if America forsakes dominance and conserves its power, global disorder can be kept at bay and the American people will be better for it. And while key figures in President Donald Trump’s orbit are all too worried about decline in racial or civilizational terms, they have their own dangerous and counterproductive ideas for how to reverse it.

On the Democratic side, many in the more traditional, liberal internationalist wing of the party maintain, with more modesty than their neoconservative counterparts, that Washington can still lead the way in renewing a global order that will broadly serve U.S. interests. Finally, the progressive wing of the party is convinced that a more restrained foreign policy will bring peace to the world and prosperity to ordinary voters, with the only negative consequences borne by the billionaire class.

But what if everyone’s right about the wrong things? The worst possible outcome would be if the restrainers prove correct about the fact that sustaining America’s global preeminence is no longer possible, and the neocons and liberal internationalists prove right about all the bad results. What if ordinary Americans really did benefit from the unique international stature of the United States, and will sorely miss it when it’s gone?

A protester holding a cardboard sign that reads “People Over Billionaires” takes part in a national day of protest in New York on March 28. Jerome Gilles/NurPhoto via Getty Images

Much as Trump’s presidency has served as a catalyst for American decline, his open disdain for the U.S. foreign-policy consensus has catalyzed the debate over what went wrong and what comes next.

Committed champions of Washington’s traditional foreign policy lament that voters no longer seem to support American global leadership. On the other side, many progressives and pro-restraint conservatives have argued that, however........

© Foreign Policy