The War That Cracked the Postwar Order Illusion |
Get audio access with any FP subscription. Subscribe Now ALREADY AN FP SUBSCRIBER? LOGIN
Get audio access with any FP subscription.
ALREADY AN FP SUBSCRIBER? LOGIN
Russia’s War in Ukraine
Understanding the conflict four years on.
Four years into Russia’s war in Ukraine, the principal actors have been radically transformed. For its part, Russia has morphed into an openly militaristic, anti-Western country. A society that after 1945 embraced the saying “anything but war” has now reconciled itself to the role of aggressor.
Western hopes that the full-scale invasion of Ukraine would catalyze resistance to Russian President Vladimir Putin’s regime proved misplaced. Russians merely adapted. Aside from Wagner Group leader Yevgeny Prigozhin’s aborted mutiny in June 2023, Putin’s grip on power has not been challenged. Dissidents have left, died, or fallen silent. Whether through propaganda, fear, or conviction, the public has acquiesced.
Four years into Russia’s war in Ukraine, the principal actors have been radically transformed. For its part, Russia has morphed into an openly militaristic, anti-Western country. A society that after 1945 embraced the saying “anything but war” has now reconciled itself to the role of aggressor.
Western hopes that the full-scale invasion of Ukraine would catalyze resistance to Russian President Vladimir Putin’s regime proved misplaced. Russians merely adapted. Aside from Wagner Group leader Yevgeny Prigozhin’s aborted mutiny in June 2023, Putin’s grip on power has not been challenged. Dissidents have left, died, or fallen silent. Whether through propaganda, fear, or conviction, the public has acquiesced.
Meanwhile, Ukraine has reforged its identity as a nation fighting for survival. By sustaining a defensive war against a much larger adversary, it has reaffirmed its sovereignty and its place in the European house. But this has come at a staggering cost: the loss of roughly one-fifth of Ukrainian territory, hundreds of thousands of people dead or wounded, millions displaced, and profound damage to its infrastructure and economy.
Yet the most consequential transformation has taken place within the Western coalition. The decades-old alliance of liberal democracies was widely seen as the world’s dominant military and economic force, capable of upholding a rules-based order. Certain features were axiomatic: U.S. leadership, NATO’s unity, and a commitment to collective deterrence.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky (center) waits for a “family photo” with European leaders and U.S. representatives during talks on how to end the war in Ukraine, seen in Berlin on Dec. 15, 2025. Among the group: NATO chief Mark Rutte (back left); U.S. special envoy Steve Witkoff (right of Zelensky); and Jared Kushner, U.S. President Donald Trump’s son-in-law (far right).Lisi Niesner/AFP via Getty Images
During the Cold War, that order was sustained not only by shared values but also by the power balance between two competing systems: the capitalist West and the communist Soviet Union. NATO’s military strength and U.S. security guarantees created clear expectations about how aggression would be met. When the Cold War ended, the institutions remained but the discipline that sustained those expectations softened, and enforced realities became assumptions.
One such assumption was that the Western coalition would not tolerate disorder in its house. Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine stress-tested that premise—and found it wanting. What began as a united front against Russian aggression in 2022 has given way to a fractured alliance with a de facto leader, the United States, now seeking a peace agreement on terms unfavorable to both Ukraine and its European allies. This transformation severely undermines long-held beliefs about the West’s unity, resolve, and credible deterrence.
Russia’s invasion did not destroy the rules-based order but, rather, revealed how uncertain the West had become about enforcing it. In its hesitant support for Ukraine, the Western coalition showed that the stable post-World War II order may have turned out to be an illusion. The longer the war in Ukraine goes on, the further it erodes Western credibility and influence—and the harder it becomes to restore the authority that the West once took for granted.
A single rose........