Social Security is on track to cut benefits by roughly 22 percent in 2032 unless Congress finds new revenue — and lawmakers are increasingly eyeing high earners to close the gap.

Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren continues using social media to generate public pressure on the Social Security cap — the maximum amount a taxpayer can earn before they no longer contribute to Social Security. In 2026, wages above $184,500 are not subject to the 6.2% Social Security tax. This notion leads some to feel the tax is regressive.

Her efforts have helped move this idea from a social post to a movement. In June, Warren and Ohio Republican Sen. Bernie Moreno co‑authored a New York Times op‑ed urging Congress to eliminate the cap. They would require workers to pay Social Security tax on every dollar of their wages, not just the first $184,500, in a move that would provide much-needed funding.

However, their social media praise for their plan to reform Social Security leaves out an important nuance — taxpayers with income above $184,500 would not receive any incremental Social Security benefits. That is, a taxpayer earning $1 million in wages would pay 6.2% of their earnings in Social Security tax, but they would only receive the same benefits as somebody earning $184,500.

This aspect makes the proposal less a Social Security contribution than a straightforward tax-rate increase on high-income taxpayers. Like any tax-rate increase, this one comes with intended and unintended consequences.

Why The Social Security Cap Exists

Social Security is a federal social insurance program funded through payroll taxes. Under Social Security, employees pay 6.2% of their wages, and employers match it with another 6.2%, for a combined 12.4%. Self-employed workers pay the full 12.4% themselves.

Since the retirement benefits are only designed to provide taxpayers with a cushion for their retirement, the tax applies only up to a ceiling, which is $184,500 in 2026. This amount rises each year with the national average wage. Once a worker’s wages pass this dollar amount, no more Social Security tax is withheld for the rest of the year. Thus, the most an employee can pay in 2026 is........

© Forbes