Looking back at the year’s West End theatre, a few shows stand out. First, the best. Vanya, starring Andrew Scott at the Duke of York’s Theatre, was an audacious and frankly barmy attempt to reimagine Chekhov’s sprawling family melodrama, Uncle Vanya, as a monologue. The risk was that it might come across as a lengthy pitch for a TV show performed by an incorrigible show-off. But Scott made it work. Copycat projects are bound to follow.

One of the year’s worst efforts, A Little Life, was based on an American novel about sexual torture and self-harm. The star, James Norton, spent most of his time on stage at the Harold Pinter hacking his forearms to bits or being kicked around by various abusers. Claret got spilled all over the place. Norton tugged his clothes off as well. Never a good sign. A decent play doesn’t need to be a peep-show.

The Pillowman, by Martin McDonagh, is regarded as a modern classic even though the script is just a re-hash of the author’s early short stories. This version, at the Duke of York’s Theatre, starred Lily Allen as a writer being investigated by secret policemen in a nasty totalitarian state. On stage, the main events were described by Allen’s character in long screeds of reminiscence which left viewers feeling that the real action was happening elsewhere.

Good luck finding a play criticising the NHS

The same problem afflicted Lyonesse, at the Harold Pinter, a play about a washed-up actress played by Kristin Scott Thomas.

QOSHE - Treading carefully / Why are theatres so cowardly? - Lloyd Evans
menu_open
Columnists Actual . Favourites . Archive
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close
Aa Aa Aa
- A +

Treading carefully / Why are theatres so cowardly?

8 6
30.12.2023

Looking back at the year’s West End theatre, a few shows stand out. First, the best. Vanya, starring Andrew Scott at the Duke of York’s Theatre, was an audacious and frankly barmy attempt to reimagine Chekhov’s sprawling family melodrama, Uncle Vanya, as a monologue. The risk was that it might come across as a lengthy pitch for a TV show performed by an........

© The Spectator


Get it on Google Play