We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close
Aa Aa Aa
- A +

Fact and fiction

26 17 42
12.01.2017

The reports about Pakistan’s former army chief general Raheel Sharif joining the 39-member Saudi coalition were finally confirmed by Pakistan’s Defence Minister Khawaja Asif, on January 6 in the Geo show, Naya Pakistan. The minister had few details to offer on the appointment.

Not surprisingly, the reports about the former chief’s appointment surfaced after he and his staff took off for Saudi Arabia reportedly on a special plane sent by the Saudi royal family. (The story about the former army chief taking up the Saudi job had first come out around mid-2016 while he was still the army chief.)

Two days later, in my programme, the PM’s spokesperson said he had no information of such an appointment. He was asked why the PM House hadn’t enquired into the facts on this important story. After all, the story involved a man who was army chief barely 40 days ago; it also involved Pakistan’s important friend, the Saudi government, and it had implications for Pakistan’s foreign policy – including relations with Iran and Russia. The story would have implications within Pakistan as well.

But the PM’s spokesperson said that he was not aware that any clarification from anyone or any institution had been sought on this story. The other participant, a retired general, also confirmed that while he also knew of the former chief’s presence in Saudi Arabia, he had no information about General Sharif’s employment with the Saudi government.

Interestingly, the only confirmation about Gen Sharif and the Saudi coalition came from the defence minister. The ISPR was mum on the story, and unable to keep to its promise to “get back” with a comment.

In the meanwhile, this report triggered anger, anguish and some hope in public space. The hopefuls argued that Sharif’s appointment as commander of the Saudi-led military coalition would enhance Pakistan’s stature and give Pakistan leverage to play a role in the Muslim world, including the ability to influence the Saudi government to engage with Iran and other countries confronting terrorism. This hope, against the backdrop of the Saudi-Iran confrontation through 2016 especially, seemed misplaced. Also with no precedent of Pakistan, despite its decades-long security engagement with Saudi Arabia, influencing the kingdom’s policy in the region, any hope of now influencing Saudi policy seems naïve. Additionally, Sharif joining a coalition with an ostensibly sectarian colour would seem to undermine Pakistan’s impressive record of having distanced itself from the sectarian-framed power struggle.

Many of us questioned the wisdom of the former army chief’s move to take up the Saudi employment. His decision to engage with the Saudis, without clearance from either the government or the GHQ and his employment only 40 days after his retirement from a position which allows him full access to Pakistan’s conventional and nuclear security setup, was highly questionable. As expected, the news of the former chief’s appointment and our criticism was also promptly carried by the foreign press, including that of India.

However, by the evening of January 9, hours after the former army chief arrived in Lahore, the story took a different turn. Five points were particularly noteworthy. One, based on the former army chief’s discussions in Riyadh, the proposed coalition will initially focus on enhancement of CT capacity including controlling terror funding, Muslim image-building etc. At present, there is no plan to raise an army and the coalition will not be involved in physically fighting terrorism. The proposed Defence Council will determine its........

© The News International